www.registerguard.com | © The Register-Guard, Eugene, Oregon | ||||||||
![]() August 26, 2003 Activist strikes over psychiatrists' faith in drug therapy By Tim Christie Since 1987, David Oaks of Eugene has been leading a quiet war against
the psychiatric establishment and its reliance on pharmaceutical drugs to
treat mental illness, sometimes against the will of patients.
Now, Oaks said, he and his organization, MindFreedom Support Coalition,
are turning to direct action, in the form of a hunger strike, to turn up
the heat on psychiatrists and drug companies.
David
Oaks A sixth member of the group dropped out of the strike Sunday because
she had lost too much weight and was starting to suffer health problems.
But about 17 other people in other parts of the United States and Europe
also began hunger strikes in solidarity, Oaks said.
At issue is the notion that mental illness is the result of a chemical
imbalance in the body that can only be corrected with drugs, he said.
Oaks became an activist after his own experiences with the mental
health system. When he was a student at Harvard, he became depressed and
overwhelmed. He said he was locked into a cell in a psychiatric unit and
forcibly injected with psychiatric drugs.
He describes MindFreedom as a coalition of 100 groups in a dozen
countries "working for a nonviolent revolution in the mental health
system."
Oaks said his group isn't opposed to the use of psychiatric drugs, but
believes that they shouldn't be the only option for mentally ill people.
"We feel choice is being squeezed out by the psychiatric drug
industry," he said. "When a family has a member in crisis ... there needs
to be a range of options: jobs, housing, counseling, peer support."
Oaks contends that there is no scientific evidence to support the
assertion that mental illness is the result of chemical imbalance.
The hunger strikers are demanding that the American Psychiatric
Association produce scientifically valid evidence that mental illness is
biologically based.
A spokeswoman for the the association, Laurie Oseran, declined comment,
but pointed to a letter that the group's medical director wrote to Oaks
before the hunger strike began.
In the letter, Dr. James Scully told Oaks the hunger strike was
"ill-advised" and said that the answers to his questions are "widely
available in the scientific literature and have been for years." He
referred to several medical texts and journals, but made no specific
citations.
A 14-member panel of medical doctors and psychologists assembled by
MindFreedom to review the evidence checked Scully's sources and found the
opposite: 10 different citations that indicate no scientific evidence
exists that mental illness is biologically based.
The hunger strikers are assembled at the Pasadena Church of Religious
Science - Oaks said it isn't connected to the Church of Scientology, a
vociferous critic of the psychiatric establishment. They picked the church
because it was available for a reasonable cost and in a major media
center.
They have had only clear broth, fruit juice, vegetable juice and coffee
or tea, Oaks said. That includes a concoction that Oaks has been making
from kale, carrots, beets and garlic.
Oaks said he's starting to feel a little weak and tired, but doesn't
know how long the strike will continue. The group is looking for an
acknowledgement from the American Psychiatric Association that it has
reasonable concerns, Oaks said.
"We feel there's some possible middle ground and we're feeling out what
that means," he said.
Failing that, "People are prepared to go on," he said. "Several people
are pretty strong and prepared to go quite a long distance."
HUNGER STRIKE
For more information on the hunger strike by members of MindFreedom
Support Coalition International:
| ||||||||
|